Monday, April 12, 2004

Peer Eval Primer

By Gary Coy
Evaluations Chairman

It has been brought to my attention that there may be some confusion amongst the membership about the peer scoring and what the scores mean. The following chart should help clear up any confusion.

A+ This score should be given to college umpires who perform in a manner consistent with what is expected of umpires above the "A" tier or any other umpires who perform in a manner consistent with that of umpires above the "A" tier.

A This score should be given to umpires who perform in a manner consistent with what is expected of an "A" tier umpire.

Low A / High B This score should be given to umpires whose performance was above what is expected of "B" umpires but not consistent with what is expected of "A" umpires.

B This score should be given when the umpire's performance was consistent with what is expected of a "B" tier umpire.

Low B / High C This score should be given to an umpire whose performance was above what is expected of a "C" umpire but not consistent with what is expected of a "B" tier umpire.

C This score should be given to an umpire whose performance was consistent with what is expected of a "C" tier umpire.

Low C This score should be given to umpires whose performance was below what is expected of "C" tier umpires.

Please adhere to these scoring guidelines.

If you have any questions, please contact me at Gary901c@msn.com